Stem Cell Wars, Volume 2, Chapter 2: Human Egg Farming
"Can either the free market or altruistic volunteers provide the human eggs needed for hESC research under Proposition 71, or will some form of coercion be necessary?"

California Politics Today #475

Sacramento, California
November 20, 2005

By Marc Strassman
Reporter
California Politics Today
Etopia Media Medical News Network
Etopia Media News Networks

This page and its contents are copyright © 2005 by Etopia Media News Networks. All rights in all media reserved.

stem cells (1998)----------------------------"Starry Night," by Vincent van Gogh (1889)


embryonic stem cell colonies from the lab of developmental biologist James Thompson
Source: University of Wisconsin-Madison.
Used with permission © University of Wisconsin Board of Regents



a chapter of Stem Cell Wars© focusing on an essential component of the embryonic stem cell creation process: the human oocyte, or egg cell

Today, November 20, 2005, Washington Post Staff Writer Rick Weiss published an article entitled "Donor Issue Slows Stem Cell Progress--S. Korea Crisis May Affect U.S. Debate," in which he highlights a central, but often undercovered, aspect of the embryonic stem cell creation process:

"With current techniques, it takes dozens of eggs to make a single cloned human embryo, which is destroyed in the process of extracting the stem cells. That means that if the field of therapeutic cloning is to advance -- a field involving the creation of cloned embryos as sources of stem cells that would be genetically matched to particular patients -- a significant number of eggs will be needed both to fuel the initial research and eventually to satisfy the demands of patients."

This Washington Post article reports on many of the same issues covered recently (last week) in these two articles published on the Etopia Media News Network web site:

"Oocytes hit the fan as Schatten ends cooperation with Hwang over alleged unethical "egg recruitment" for cloning research" (November 15, 2005)

"Proposition 71 stem cell quagmire deepens as 'egg recruitment' and 'cellular vampirism' issues receive heightened scrutiny" (November 17, 2005)

The publication of this article in the Washington Post, one of the nation's premier "newspapers of record," clearly indicates the new prominence into which the issue of "egg recruitment" for embryonic stem cell research and, to a lesser extent, for use in the in vitro fertilization (IVF) process, has now fallen.

Etopia Media News Network has been covering this issue since before the November 2, 2004, election in California which passed Proposition 71, the Stem Cell Initiative, which, through its authorization of $3 billion in general revenue state bonds (to be repaid with at around at least $6 billion in California taxpayer money) for purposes of embryonic stem cell research based on the use of human egg cells ("oocytes"), has now generated heightened public interest and even some debate by "electeds" about this issue.

Accordingly, this seemed an appropriate time to aggregate and re-publish links to a collection of Etopia Media News Network articles dealing with the subject of the raw material of embryonic stem cells: human oocytes.

Below, you'll find links to 13 Etopia Media News Network articles concerned with the subject of "egg recruitment," also known as "egg farming." Following those links, you'll find additional ones to three articles by Judy Norsigian, a founding member of the Boston Women's Health Book Collective and a contributor to the 1998 update of Our Bodies, Ourselves, one by Rebecca Dresser, a member of the The President's Council on Bioethics, and a copy of SB 18, a bill by California State Senator Deborah Ortiz intended to protect the rights of women donating eggs for embryonic stem cell research under the provisions of California Proposition 71.




"A "No on 71" wrap-up, with a suggestion for how to cope with its likely passage on November 2nd (October 30, 2004)

"Stanford University confers the gift of immortality—on itself" (November 8, 2004)

"California State Senator Deborah Ortiz introduces SB 18, the 'Proposition 71 Public Accountability Act'" (December 9, 2004)

"California State Senator Deborah Ortiz explains SB 18, while Proposition 71's principal author is unanimously nominated to head the ICOC created by that measure" (December 15, 2004)

"Fears of 'female human egg farming' grow, while local, national, and global battles over human cloning rage" (April 17, 2005)

"Betty Poirier, Massachusetts State Representative, discusses the possible exploitation of women as 'egg farms' for embryonic stem cell research and treatments" (April 18, 2005)

"Richard Doerflinger at United States Conference of Catholic Bishops talks about embryonic stem cell research" (April 27, 2005)

"Jonathan Moreno, co-chair, National Academy of Sciences Embryonic Stem Cell Research Guidelines Committee, talks about these guidelines" (April 27, 2005)

"Judy Norsigian, Executive Director, Our Bodies Ourselves, talks about embryonic stem cell research, calls for a moratorium on somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT)" (April 27, 2005)

"Dr. David Adamson, Chairman and CEO of Advanced Reproductive Care, Inc. (ARC), talks about egg donations for embryonic stem cell research" (May 4, 2005)

"Stanford bio-ethicist Mildred Cho says properly-informed and financially-uncompensated 'research donors' will still want to donate their eggs for embryonic stem cell/bio-medical research" (May 23, 2005)

"Oocytes hit the fan as Schatten ends cooperation with Hwang over alleged unethical "egg recruitment" for cloning research" (November 15, 2005)

"Proposition 71 stem cell quagmire deepens as 'egg recruitment' and 'cellular vampirism' issues receive heightened scrutiny" (November 17, 2005)

additional links on the subject of "egg recruitment" or "egg farming"

"Egg Donation for IVF and Stem Cell Research: Time to Weigh the Risks to Women's Health," by Judy Norsigian

"Risks to Women in Embryo Cloning," by Judy Norsigian

"Stem Cell Research and Embryo Cloning: Involving Laypersons in the Public Debates," by Judy Norsigian

"Stem Cell Research: Woman who donate eggs for research also deserve premium care," by Rebecca Dresser

"SB 18," by California State Senator Deborah Ortiz

previous installments of Stem Cell Wars©

On August 28, 2005, Etopia Media News Networks published

Stem Cell Wars, Volume 1

8-28-05: Stem Cell Wars, Volume 1 (California Politics Today™ #410)

On October 31, 2005, Etopia Media News Networks published:

Stem Cell Wars, Volume 2, Chapter 1

10-31-05: Stem Cell Wars, Volume 2, Chapter 1 (California Politics Today™ #454)


 



Join the "California Politics Today™" mailing list (unless you're already on another Etopia Media mailing list)

Just send an empty e-mail to CAPolDay-subscribe@yahoogroups.com.


Get into the swing of things with additional Etopia Media News Network articles and interviews and Google Alerts

To access additional, recent articles from the Etopia Media News Networks web site, as crawled and cataloged on the Google News web site, click here.

To sign up for Google Alerts whenever a new Etopia Media News Networks article appears on Google News, click here.